In the aftermath of Hurricane Katrina, here's your response for the next time some closet bigot or one of their enablers asks you why the folks in the 9th Ward of New Orleans can't "get their act together" like those can-do, salt-of-the-earth, real Americans in Mississippi...
Since Katrina, Mississippi Gov. Haley Barbour has received heaps of praise for his political savvy -- and ability to use his GOP connections to get a lion's share of federal relief funds for his state.
One eye-opening item we found is just how lopsided Mississippi's take of Katrina relief has been:
Consider the Gulf Coast housing crisis, one of the key issues that has kept nearly half the population of New Orleans from returning to the city since Katrina. More than 75 percent of the housing damage from the storm was in Louisiana, but Mississippi has received 70 percent of the funds through FEMA's Alternative Housing Pilot Program. Of the $388 million available, FEMA gave a Mississippi program offering upgraded trailers more than $275 million. Meanwhile, the agency awarded Louisiana's "Katrina Cottage" program, which features more permanent modular homes for storm victims, a mere $75 million.
This truly gives the lie to all the finger-waggers in conservative talk radio land, on our television screens, on the web and in print who hold up the relative progress of Mississippi's reconstruction as a example of a self-reliant community picking itself up without the aid of government "hand-outs". For years now we've listened to these windbags excoriate the residents of New Orleans for supposedly demanding government handouts while they, being morally depraved and underserving of empathy, do nothing for themselves, unlike those plucky residents of Mississippi.
Well, hardy-har-har. Looky where all the "handouts" went after all. You will, of course, hear nothing of this from any of these people.
[More after the jump]
Now, what's the difference between Lousiana and Mississippi that might account for this disparity? Well, MS has a Republican governor and LA has a Democratic one. But that's not the only reason to suspect that the disparity is borne of pure political motivation. The grossly under-reported appointment of none other than Karl Rove himself, Maximum Ruler's Chief Political Advisor, as the "Czar" of Gulf Coast reconstruction is the smoking gun in this case. By "Czar" I'm assuming that means he controlled how it was run and it appears that he decided the money should go to Mississippi and it's Republican governor instead of Louisiana, where the bulk of the devastation occured.
Is anyone really surprised by this? Putting the political goals and interests of the GOP generally and George W. Bush specifically ahead of the public good is not just a bug in how the Bush administration operates. It's a feature. It is a defining characteristic of literally everything they do.
But here's the thing that should make the blood of any Louisiana resident's blood run cold. Bush carried the state of Louisiana by an overwhelming margin in each of the last two presidential elections. They voted him in en masse and he, in turn, did this to them.
That really is the big picture in a nutshell. Bush and GOP plays on a wide array of boogeymen to get people to vote for them. They hold themselves up as stalwarts against the perceived intrusions of one hated group or another and a certain segment of the population buys it to their eventual peril.
So people vote for Bush and Republicans because they they think these folks will "git the blacks", "git the faggots", "git the A-Rabs", the immigrants, the liberals, the secular humanists or whoever happens to be the right's Satan of the Month at the time. But in the end, the only people they're is really going "git" is YOU. Read more...
This Katrina anniversary edition would be remiss without the inclusion of Naomi Klein's work on the big-business end of the story. The Bush administration's response to the human dimension of the disaster may have been sorely lacking but it's big-business relief program was swift and sure. We all know how quickly the president suspended prevailing wage requirements in the disaster zone, ensuring that the reconstruction jobs created went, not to local workers displaced from their homes and jobs, but to illegal and migrant workers imported from far and wide to be abused in this deregulated-by-fiat workplace.
That's only one example of how, while citizens drowned in the rising filth that flooded the 9th ward, the big business bailout went off instantly without a hitch. But there so much more. It's all part of the third-worldization of the American workforce disguised as the "free market".
This is all made politically possible by the self-supporting delusion that our anti-government, privatization-crazed leaders have constructed in defense of their policies. Now that they have control of the government, anytime the government does something well (or at least has an excuse to say it did) they claim it as a victory for thier privatization policies and proof that we need even more of them. If the government fails (and fails badly, as with Katrina) they claim it as proof that government solutions are not the answer, therefore it is a victory for their privatization policies and proof that we need even more of them. It is this self-perpetuating loop of lunacy that led us to the disaster we all witnessed on this day last year.
The Red Cross has just announced a new disaster-response partnership with Wal-Mart. When the next hurricane hits, it will be a co-production of Big Aid and Big Box.
This, apparently, is the lesson learned from the government's calamitous response to Hurricane Katrina: Businesses do disaster better.
"It's all going to be private enterprise before it's over," Billy Wagner, emergency management chief for the Florida Keys, currently under hurricane watch for Tropical Storm Ernesto, said in April. "They've got the expertise. They've got the resources."
But before this new consensus goes any further, perhaps it's time to take a look at where the privatization of disaster began, and where it will inevitably lead.
The first step was the government's abdication of its core responsibility to protect the population from disasters. Under the Bush administration, whole sectors of the government, most notably the Department of Homeland Security, have been turned into glorified temp agencies, with essential functions contracted out to private companies. The theory is that entrepreneurs, driven by the profit motive, are always more efficient (please suspend hysterical laughter).
[Snip]
But here's the catch: The U.S. government is going broke, in no small part thanks to this kind of loony spending. The national debt is $8-trillion; the federal budget deficit is at least $260-billion. That means that sooner rather than later, the contracts are going to dry up. And no one knows this better than the companies themselves. Ralph Sheridan, chief executive of Good Harbor Partners, one of hundreds of new counter-terrorism companies, explains that "expenditures by governments are episodic and come in bubbles." Insiders call it the "homeland security bubble."
When it bursts, firms such as Bechtel, Fluor and Blackwater will lose their primary revenue stream. They will still have all their high-tech gear giving them the ability to respond to disasters -- while the government will have let that precious skill whither away -- but now they will rent back the tax-funded infrastructure at whatever price they choose.
Here's a snapshot of what could be in store in the not-too-distant future: helicopter rides off of rooftops in flooded cities ($5,000 a pop, $7,000 for families, pets included), bottled water and "meals ready to eat" ($50 per person, steep, but that's supply and demand) and a cot in a shelter with a portable shower (show us your biometric ID -- developed on a lucrative Homeland Security contract -- and we'll track you down later with the bill. Don't worry, we have ways: spying has been outsourced too)...
This article is actually a long-awated follow-up to Klein's excellent piece, written last year before Katrina hit but after the tsunami in Indonesia, "The Rise of Disaster Capitalism". Prescient it was, a highly recommended read. I ought to add to my "Web Gems" list.
Addendum, 8/30/2006: See also: "Report: Rampant 'Disaster Profiteering' Abuses Needlessly Slowing Rebuilding of New Orleans, Gulf Coast After Katrina"
While "disaster profiteers" -- including Halliburton's Kellogg, Brown & Root (KBR) and Bechtel Group Inc. -- double dip to add to their profits from the also troubled reconstruction of Iraq, local companies and laborers in New Orleans and the rest of the Katrina-devastated Gulf Coast region are systematically getting the short end of the stick, according to a major new report from the nonprofit CorpWatch.
A CorpWatch analysis of FEMA's records shows that "fully 90 percent of the first wave of (the post-Katrina reconstruction) contracts awarded -- including some of the biggest no-bid contracts to date -- went to companies from outside the three worst-affected states. As of July 2006, after months of controversy and Congressional hearings, companies from Louisiana, Mississippi and Alabama had increased their share of the total contracts to a combined 16.6 percent." The CorpWatch analysis shows that more federal reconstruction contracts have gone to Virginia and Indiana -- usually large, politically connected corporations -- than to any of the three Katrina-devastated states.
Titled "Big, Easy Money: Disaster Profiteering on the American Gulf Coast," the CorpWatch report also exposes abusive "contracting charge pyramids" where the companies doing the actual reconstruction work often get only a tiny (and insufficient) fraction of the taxpayer money awarded for projects and widespread non-payment of local companies and laborers, including what has been alleged to be the deliberate and systematic exploitation of immigrant workers, including undocumented individuals.
CorpWatch Director Pratap Chatterjee said: "One year after disaster struck, the slow-motion rebuilding of the Gulf Coast region looks identical to what has happened to date in Afghanistan and Iraq. We see a pattern of profiteering, waste and failure -- due to the same flawed contracting system and even many of the same 'players.' The process of getting Katrina- stricken areas back on their feet is needlessly behind schedule, in part, due to the shunning of local business people in favor of politically connected corporations from elsewhere in the U.S. that have used their clout to win lucrative no-bid contracts with little or no accountability and who have done little or no work while ripping off the taxpayer."
Exactly one year ago today Hurricane Katrina struck the Gulf Coast region and devastated communities in Louisiana and Mississippi. To mark this anniversary there will be more than enough retrospective news pieces brought to us via television, radio and print recounting the strength of the storm, the deaths, the millions of dollars in damage and the aftermath.
But there's an added twist as well. This anniversary coincides with mid-term election season. So in addition to the usual fare we will also have plenty of opportunities to see our elected officials, more interested in the reconstruction of their political fortunes than that of the Gulf Coast, once again descend upon the scene of the tragedy to practice a little damage control. With an eye on this coming wave of cynical, PR-driven insults to our collective intelligence let us take this first anniversary as an opportunity to cross-check what is surely to be said today against past commentary on the subject, be it from the Bush Administration, the Republican Party in general or the conservative movement as a whole.
After Katrina's assault the nation's "3rd Coast" was hit a second time by windstorm of a different kind, the sound of which differed noticeably from what we'll hear over the next few days. The victims of Katrina were routinely dismissed and insulted by the Bush administration, its supporters in congress and the right-wing media in a disturbing orgy of victim-blaming and demonization.
What follows is a quick, partial collection of what I consider to be some of the most infamous Hurricane Katrina quotes from the right wing over the last year. Your results may vary. While compiling this list I came to realize that there are so many examples of right-wing hate-speech directed at the victims of this tragedy that I could never do them justice in a single blog post. So, I ask that any egregious omissions the reader may notice here be added in the comments section via the link below. The best will be used as an update to this post (with thanks, of course). Until then, without any further adieu, I humbly present the Hurricane Katrina Rhetorical Year in Review:
August 31, 2005: Just 2 days after Katrina hit, while people were still languishing and dying in the aftermath, the Republican Speaker of the House, Dennis Hastert suggested that lawmakers think about whether it's worth the effort to rebuild New Orleans saying: "It doesn't make sense to me," and "It looks like that place could be bulldozed."
September 1, 2005: Homeland Security Chief Michael Chertoffspeaking NBC's Today show: "The critical thing was to get people out of there before the disaster... Some people chose not to obey that order. That was a mistake on their part."
September 4, 2005: Again, while people are still dying in the aftermath, the GOP's #3 man in the Senate, Rick Santorum (R-PA) , is quoted on WTAE-TV in Pittsburgh, PA saying, "I mean, you have people who don't heed those warnings and then put people at risk as a result of not heeding those warnings. There may be a need to look at tougher penalties on those who decide to ride it out and understand that there are consequences to not leaving."
September 5, 2005: Former First Lady and current First Mom, Barbara Bush, speaking on the flood of displaced Katrina victims seeking shelter in Texas: "What I’m hearing which is sort of scary is they all want to stay in Texas. Everyone is so overwhelmed by the hospitality... And so many of the people in the arena here, you know, were underprivileged anyway, so this--this (she chuckles slightly) is working very well for them."
Yeah, they're really getting over, the lucky duckies.
September 6, 2005: Columnist Karen H. Pittman of Renew America, a vehicle of the perennial GOP candidate for something or another, Alan Keyes, writes this about Katrina's victims: "I can't help it, but I have an inherent antipathy towards that certain sub-species of human animal that is now commandeering the streets of that fetid city, truly now a razed City of the Dead. I haven't the sufficiently impoverished vernacular to express just how thoroughly revolted I am by these mack daddies and gangstars and brazen bitches-with-FATitudes(-in-these-lowlife-latitudes) when I hear them squawking on-camera about how "ain't nobody did nuthin' fa us" — when they were told to leave!... "I say let the gangsters drown in their toxic soup. If they aren't killed by Guardsmen, and they aren't rescued, they will soon be dead of typhoid. So be it. They chose."
Speaks for itself.
September 9, 2005: The Wall Street Journal reports that Republican State Representative from Baton Rouge, Richard H. Baker, was overheard saying, "We finally cleaned up public housing in New Orleans. We couldn't do it, but God did."
Again, it speaks for itself.
September 9, 2005: Former aide to President Nixon, convicted Watergate felon and one of the leading lights of the so-called "Christian" right, Charles Colson, speaking on the Trinity Broadcast Network said, "God allowed Katrina to happen to bring attention to lack of preparation for terrorist attack."
September 13, 2005: Fox News' Bill O'Reilly blames the victims. As documented by Media Matters for America, defending the miserable response of the Bush administration to the disaster on his radio program O'Reilly claimed that "many, many, many" of Katrina's victims were "drug-addicted", "thugs" who "can't carry on a conversation", "will never, ever be able to fend for themselves and make a living" and "spend all their entitlement money on drugs and alchohol."
September 17, 2005: Speaking on Fox News' Newsday, conservative columnist Jim Pinkertonaccused Katrina's victims of "whining all the time on TV to get more federal money."
October 17, 2005:Reverend Jesse Lee Peterson, founder and president of Brotherhood Organization of a New Destiny (BOND) and prominent figure in the faux-black group, Project 21 had this to say about the victims in New Orleans: "75 percent of New Orleans residents had left the city, it was primarily immoral, welfare-pampered blacks that stayed behind and waited for the government to bail them out."
October 24, 2005: Conservative talk show host, Neil Boortz, speaking about a female victim of Hurricane Katrina, recommends she take up prostitution in lieu of receiving federal aid: "Rolanda is worried about being evicted from the hotel. She says, 'We have a place to stay. We have food. The only worry is how long it will last.'" That's all she's worried about, the only worry. And it goes through the whole article here talking about how fed up Rolanda is with FEMA [Federal Emergency Management Agency] and how she spends all this time on a computer looking for more free housing. Not one mention in the entire story anywhere about the "W" word, W-O-R-K, work, job. I dare say she could walk out of that hotel and walk 100 yards in either direction on Fulton Industrial Boulevard [the street on which the hotel is located] here in Atlanta and have a job. What's that? Well, no, no, no... If that's the only way she can take care of herself, it sure beats the hell out of sucking off the taxpayers."
June 6, 2006: Conservative radio talk show host, Neil Boortz again: "I love talking to you about these Katrina refugees. I mean, so many of them have turned out to be complete bums, just debris. Debris that Hurricane Katrina washed across the country."
July 6, 2006: The Sheriff of Bigotry, St. Tamany Parish, LA Sheriff Jack Strain made this "law and order" statement to a local TV station in New Orleans about displaced Katrina victims who may pass through his jurisdiction: "Now I don’t get into calling people names and all that fact, but if you’re gonna walk the streets of St. Tammany Parish with dreadlocks and "Chee Wee" hairstyles, then you can expect to be getting a visit from a sheriff’s deputy."
Yes, even as this disaster was still unfolding there were some among us who could not resist the urge to dance on the victims' graves . On this solemn anniversary, as we reflect on the loss of a unique piece of American history and culture -- a whole American city -- and, of course, the thousands of fellow Americans who were lost or disposessed, do also take a moment to also remember what was said about them and by whom.